I will try to be as concise as possible. A friend recommended according to my specifications to try Tom Ford Tobacco Vanille or Amouage for a tobacco or smoky scent. I'm a bit particular and am looking for a good tobacco/ tobacco leaf smell with some rum thrown in and/or smokiness too, while not being too sweet. The less sweet, the better (for me). I might consider black pepper scent thrown in. Any suggestions? Please name as many that comes to mind with good details to help steer me in the right direction. I hope I this post makes sense. Let me know. Re: A Certain Tobacco Smoky Smell Tobacco Vanille is elegantly made but it's very, very sweet, so that might not be what you want. I've tried ... [Read more]